Back to Cases

United States v. Hayes (BitMEX) (2023)

Analysis ID: h4k9l81-nij0-ji9i-6j7725l292n6
Predicted Outcome
2 Years Probation
Confidence Score: 98%
Analysis Type
Criminal Case
Jurisdiction:Federal
Citations:5

Probability Distribution

Probation Completed Successfully90%
Probation Violated - Prison Time8%
Early Termination2%

Legal Reasoning

1

Defendant pleaded guilty to violating Bank Secrecy Act.

2

BitMEX failed to implement required Anti-Money Laundering (AML) program.

3

Platform knowingly served U.S. customers without proper registration.

4

Inadequate Know Your Customer (KYC) verification allowed illicit actors.

5

Platform processed billions in cryptocurrency transactions without reporting.

6

$100 million fine reflects severity of BSA violations.

7

2-year probation sentence reflects cooperation and acceptance of responsibility.

Tribunal Logo

Legal Citations

31 U.S.C. § 5318(h) - Bank Secrecy Act AML Program Requirements

Statute

Requires financial institutions to establish AML compliance programs.

31 U.S.C. § 5322 - Criminal Penalties for BSA Violations

Statute

Criminal penalties for willful violations of BSA requirements.

18 U.S.C. § 1960 - Operating Unlicensed Money Transmitting Business

Statute

Prohibits operation of money transmitting business without state licenses.

United States v. Murgio, Bank Secrecy Act Bitcoin Case

Case Law

Precedent for applying BSA to cryptocurrency exchanges.

Counter-Arguments

  • •Defense argued lack of clarity in BSA application to cryptocurrency platforms.
  • •Company claimed good faith efforts to comply with evolving regulations.
  • •Defense emphasized cooperation with authorities and remedial measures.
  • •Argued industry-wide compliance challenges mitigate culpability.

What Could Flip the Verdict

  • 1.Violation of probation terms could result in incarceration.
  • 2.Failure to pay $100M fine could trigger additional penalties.
  • 3.Discovery of unreported criminal conduct could lead to new charges.
  • 4.Successful completion of probation may lead to early termination.